Large change programmes fail less on the plan than on the culture. Ten practical levers, from rules and goals to rewards and the workplace, help to make the new way of working the normal way.

Every large-scale change sooner or later runs into culture. That is no surprise: culture is the largely invisible system of beliefs and habits that determines how people actually behave in an organisation. You cannot see it in an organisation chart, but you notice it the moment something has to change.

I first wrote about this in 2001 and revisited it in 2011. The lesson has not changed since: a new strategy, structure or system only works when the everyday reality of the organisation changes with it. If the old rules, rewards and routines stay in place, they quietly pull people back to the old way of working.

Ten levers

Timothy Galpin describes ten cultural components to address when implementing change (Galpin, 1996). I use them as a checklist: for each lever, does it support the new way of working, or the old one?

  • Rules and policies: remove rules that block the change and document the new way of working.
  • Goals and measurement: measure what you want to see more of.
  • Customs and norms: replace habits that keep the old way alive, for example long written reports by short face-to-face meetings.
  • Training: train people in the new processes, preferably hands-on and in real situations.
  • Ceremonies and events: celebrate progress and recognise the people and teams who make the change work.
  • Management behaviour: managers set the example; link promotion and pay to the desired behaviour.
  • Rewards and recognition: reward the new goals; a system that only rewards individual results undermines any attempt to build teamwork.
  • Communication: show commitment in how you communicate, with consistent messages through several channels before, during and after the transition.
  • Physical environment: make the workplace fit the change, whether that means shared spaces for exchanging knowledge or more time with customers outside the office.
  • Organisational structure: let the structure support the change, for example by combining overlapping units or organising around customers instead of functions.

What this means for leaders and boards

Two things stand out in practice. First, the levers work together: new values on the wall mean little if goals, rewards and promotions still favour the old behaviour. Second, management behaviour weighs heaviest. People watch what leaders do, who gets promoted and what gets measured, far more than what is announced.

For a board, that gives one practical question to ask about every major change programme: which of these ten levers are actually being changed, and which have been left as they were? The answer usually says more about the chances of success than the plan itself.

Sources

  1. Galpin, T. J. (1996). The Human Side of Change: A Practical Guide to Organization Redesign. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

← All insights